

John “JP” Hay, of Geneva, New York, passed away on November 12, 2026, at the age of 70.
Born in Lyons, New York, John spent much of his childhood growing up in Southern California before eventually making his way back to New York, settling in Geneva to raise his family.
A proud veteran of the United States Coast Guard, John served aboard the USCGC Polar Star, an icebreaking vessel. His time in the Coast Guard was something he always looked back on with pride. Whenever someone thanked him for his service, his response was simple and sincere: “It was my pleasure.”
John was happiest outdoors and always up for an adventure. From skydiving and homemade boat races during the spring thaw to riding every roller coaster he could with his daughters and grandsons, he embraced life's thrills, both big and small. He loved camping, kayaking, fishing, and later in life, discovering a passion for disc golf. Whether it was a daring adventure or a quiet afternoon outside, John knew how to make the most of every moment.
He had a quick wit, a wonderful sense of humor, and an appreciation for a good joke. He loved to laugh, but perhaps even more, he loved making others laugh.
Above all, John treasured time spent with his family, especially his grandsons. He could often be found cheering them on from the sidelines, playing ball in the backyard, or sharing a little advice along the way. Some of his favorite afternoons were spent picking Hayden up from the school bus and heading out for a round of disc golf. Those everyday moments, filled with laughter, encouragement, and time together, were among the things he cherished most.
John is survived by his wife, Cindy Hay (formerly McMahon); his daughters, Kristina (Chris) Tiefert and Kimberley Hay; and his beloved grandsons, Hayden and Carter Tiefert, and Ryan Donnelly. He is also survived by his sister, Debby Celaya of Trona, California; his brother, Larry (Deanna) Hay of Bridger, Montana; and many nieces and nephews who loved him dearly.
He was preceded in death by his parents, John Hamilton Hay and Mary (Smith) Hay; his brother, Jeffrey Hay of Florida; and his brother-in-law, Joe Celaya.
John will be remembered for his humor, his adventurous spirit, his love of the outdoors, his pride in serving his country, and the happiness he found in life's simplest moments. Most of all, he will be remembered for the love he shared with his family and the countless memories they will carry with them.
In accordance with John's wishes, no services will be held.
SHARE OBITUARYSHARE
v.1.18.1